ILLINOIS DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION PAGE: 1 06/12/08 10:12:04 U N I T P R I C E T A B U L A T I O N O F B I D S LETTING DATE: 01/18/2008 LETTING TYPE: SCHEDULED CONTRACT NUMBER: 76B19 LETTING ITEM NUMBER: 079 RESPONSIBLE DISTRICT: 08 BIDS LOCKED: Y SECTION: 9-1RS-2 COUNTY: WASHINGTON ESTIMATE: -------------------------- SUMMARY OF CONTRACTOR BIDS -------------------------- "AS READ" SUMMATION SUMMATION OF NBR BIDR CONTR COMB ITEM CONTR BIDDER OF BIDDER CALCULATED LOW BIDR CALC BLANK NBR BIDDER NAME GROUP COMB GRP NBR GROUP TOTAL PRICE EXTENSIONS EXTENSIONS BID EXTENSION DIFF BIDS 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. NO ALT 904,016.08 904,016.08 904,016.08 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. NO ALT 865,885.05 * 865,885.05 865,885.05 * 3157 The Kilian Corporation NO ALT 903,253.12 903,253.12 903,253.12 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. NO ALT 916,627.31 916,627.31 916,627.31 **** TOTAL GROUP NO ALT PAY ITEMS FOR THIS CONTRACT = 31 ---------------------- DETAIL CONTRACTOR BIDS ---------------------- ITEM NBR ITEM DESCRIPTION UNIT OF UNIT BIDDER CALCULATED BIDR CALC BIDR NBR BIDDER NAME QUANTITY MEASURE PRICE EXTENSION EXTENSION EXTENSION DIFF 40600200 BIT MATLS PR CT 30.000 TON 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 0.0100 0.30 0.30 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 401.6700 12,050.10 12,050.10 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 173.5900 5,207.70 5,207.70 3157 The Kilian Corporation 0.0100 0.30 0.30 40600300 AGG PR CT 141.000 TON 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 0.0100 1.41 1.41 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 0.0000 0.00 0.00 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 0.0000 0.00 0.00 3157 The Kilian Corporation 0.0100 1.41 1.41 40600645 LEV BIND MM N90 1,842.000 TON 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 70.9000 130,597.80 130,597.80 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 60.3000 111,072.60 111,072.60 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 64.9400 119,619.48 119,619.48 3157 The Kilian Corporation 60.5000 111,441.00 111,441.00 40600982 HMA SURF REM BUTT JT 201.000 SQ YD 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 37.3100 7,499.31 7,499.31 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 5.0000 1,005.00 1,005.00 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 14.7600 2,966.76 2,966.76 3157 The Kilian Corporation 4.0000 804.00 804.00 40600990 TEMPORARY RAMP 192.000 SQ YD 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 0.0100 1.92 1.92 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 12.5600 2,411.52 2,411.52 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 10.0900 1,937.28 1,937.28 3157 The Kilian Corporation 0.0100 1.92 1.92 40603345 HMA SC "D" N90 5,351.000 TON 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 69.6300 372,590.13 372,590.13 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 64.2700 343,908.77 343,908.77 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 66.2900 354,717.79 354,717.79 3157 The Kilian Corporation 63.0000 337,113.00 337,113.00 40800050 INCIDENTAL HMA SURF 33.000 TON 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 69.6300 2,297.79 2,297.79 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 64.2700 2,120.91 2,120.91 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 332.2600 10,964.58 10,964.58 3157 The Kilian Corporation 185.0000 6,105.00 6,105.00 44000152 HMA SURF REM 3/4 44,179.000 SQ YD 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 1.1500 50,805.85 50,805.85 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 0.7400 32,692.46 32,692.46 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 0.5500 24,298.45 24,298.45 3157 The Kilian Corporation 0.8500 37,552.15 37,552.15 44000155 HMA SURF REM 1 1/2 11,736.000 SQ YD 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 1.1500 13,496.40 13,496.40 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 1.8400 21,594.24 21,594.24 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 2.0100 23,589.36 23,589.36 3157 The Kilian Corporation 2.2500 26,406.00 26,406.00 44201765 CL D PATCH T2 10 69.000 SQ YD 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 69.1100 4,768.59 4,768.59 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 98.9000 6,824.10 6,824.10 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 105.7800 7,298.82 7,298.82 3157 The Kilian Corporation 131.0000 9,039.00 9,039.00 44201771 CL D PATCH T4 10 1,166.000 SQ YD 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 69.1100 80,582.26 80,582.26 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 76.9500 89,723.70 89,723.70 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 105.7800 123,339.48 123,339.48 3157 The Kilian Corporation 95.0000 110,770.00 110,770.00 44300200 STRIP REF CR CON TR 2,558.000 FOOT 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 1.4500 3,709.10 3,709.10 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 1.4900 3,811.42 3,811.42 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 0.8600 2,199.88 2,199.88 3157 The Kilian Corporation 0.8000 2,046.40 2,046.40 48101200 AGGREGATE SHLDS B 387.000 TON 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 0.0000 0.00 0.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 28.2000 10,913.40 10,913.40 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 37.9600 14,690.52 14,690.52 3157 The Kilian Corporation 33.0000 12,771.00 12,771.00 48203100 HMA SHOULDERS 2,482.000 TON 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 59.0000 146,438.00 146,438.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 54.8100 136,038.42 136,038.42 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 57.6900 143,186.58 143,186.58 3157 The Kilian Corporation 56.0000 138,992.00 138,992.00 67000400 ENGR FIELD OFFICE A 6.000 CAL MO 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 1,200.0000 7,200.00 7,200.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 1,660.0000 9,960.00 9,960.00 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 1,280.4900 7,682.94 7,682.94 3157 The Kilian Corporation 1,200.0000 7,200.00 7,200.00 67100100 MOBILIZATION 1.000 L SUM 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 28,578.0000 28,578.00 28,578.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 21,497.7500 21,497.75 21,497.75 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 9,758.9100 9,758.91 9,758.91 3157 The Kilian Corporation 49,225.0000 49,225.00 49,225.00 70100460 TRAF CONT-PROT 701306 1.000 L SUM 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 7,550.0000 7,550.00 7,550.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 7,500.0000 7,500.00 7,500.00 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 3,962.1800 3,962.18 3,962.18 3157 The Kilian Corporation 3,600.0000 3,600.00 3,600.00 70102622 TR CONT & PROT 701502 1.000 L SUM 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 1,500.0000 1,500.00 1,500.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 5,000.0000 5,000.00 5,000.00 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 3,727.6900 3,727.69 3,727.69 3157 The Kilian Corporation 4,955.0000 4,955.00 4,955.00 70102635 TR CONT & PROT 701701 1.000 L SUM 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 1,750.0000 1,750.00 1,750.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 2,500.0000 2,500.00 2,500.00 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 1,067.0700 1,067.07 1,067.07 3157 The Kilian Corporation 500.0000 500.00 500.00 70300100 SHORT-TERM PAVT MKING 9,952.000 FOOT 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 0.0000 0.00 0.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 0.0000 0.00 0.00 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 0.5000 4,976.00 4,976.00 3157 The Kilian Corporation 0.0100 99.52 99.52 70300220 TEMP PVT MK LINE 4 51,641.000 FOOT 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 0.0000 0.00 0.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 0.0000 0.00 0.00 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 0.0000 0.00 0.00 3157 The Kilian Corporation 0.0000 0.00 0.00 70301000 WORK ZONE PAVT MK REM 3,285.000 SQ FT 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 0.0000 0.00 0.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 0.0000 0.00 0.00 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 0.0000 0.00 0.00 3157 The Kilian Corporation 0.0100 32.85 32.85 78000100 THPL PVT MK LTR & SYM 333.000 SQ FT 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 3.0000 999.00 999.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 3.0000 999.00 999.00 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 3.2000 1,065.60 1,065.60 3157 The Kilian Corporation 3.0500 1,015.65 1,015.65 78000200 THPL PVT MK LINE 4 51,661.000 FOOT 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 0.3200 16,531.52 16,531.52 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 0.3200 16,531.52 16,531.52 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 0.3400 17,564.74 17,564.74 3157 The Kilian Corporation 0.3300 17,048.13 17,048.13 78000400 THPL PVT MK LINE 6 487.000 FOOT 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 1.5000 730.50 730.50 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 1.6000 779.20 779.20 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 1.6000 779.20 779.20 3157 The Kilian Corporation 1.5200 740.24 740.24 78000600 THPL PVT MK LINE 12 325.000 FOOT 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 3.0000 975.00 975.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 3.0000 975.00 975.00 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 3.2000 1,040.00 1,040.00 3157 The Kilian Corporation 3.0500 991.25 991.25 78100100 RAISED REFL PAVT MKR 320.000 EACH 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 24.0000 7,680.00 7,680.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 24.0000 7,680.00 7,680.00 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 25.6100 8,195.20 8,195.20 3157 The Kilian Corporation 24.7500 7,920.00 7,920.00 78300200 RAISED REF PVT MK REM 322.000 EACH 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 8.6000 2,769.20 2,769.20 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 8.7900 2,830.38 2,830.38 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 8.9600 2,885.12 2,885.12 3157 The Kilian Corporation 5.0000 1,610.00 1,610.00 80300100 LOCATE UNDERGR CABLE 50.000 FOOT 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 5.0000 250.00 250.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 5.1700 258.50 258.50 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 6.4700 323.50 323.50 3157 The Kilian Corporation 5.1000 255.00 255.00 88600100 DET LOOP T1 778.000 FOOT 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 5.0000 3,890.00 3,890.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 5.1700 4,022.26 4,022.26 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 11.4200 8,884.76 8,884.76 3157 The Kilian Corporation 5.1000 3,967.80 3,967.80 88600600 DET LOOP REPL 902.000 FOOT 1034 Christ Bros. Asphalt, Inc. 12.0000 10,824.00 10,824.00 2688 Howell Asphalt Company & Howell Paving, Inc. 12.4000 11,184.80 11,184.80 5609 Southern Illinois Asphalt Co., Inc. 11.8600 10,697.72 10,697.72 3157 The Kilian Corporation 12.2500 11,049.50 11,049.50