ILLINOIS DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION PAGE: 1 04/12/06 10:01:20 U N I T P R I C E T A B U L A T I O N O F B I D S LETTING DATE: 03/10/2006 LETTING TYPE: SCHEDULED CONTRACT NUMBER: 91326 LETTING ITEM NUMBER: 043 RESPONSIBLE DISTRICT: 07 BIDS LOCKED: Y SECTION: 04-00006-00-RP COUNTY: MACON ESTIMATE: STATE JOB NUMBER: C-95-301-05 MUNICIPALITY: FORSYTH PROJECT NUMBER: NCPD-0115/053/000 -------------------------- SUMMARY OF CONTRACTOR BIDS -------------------------- "AS READ" SUMMATION SUMMATION OF NBR BIDR CONTR COMB ITEM CONTR BIDDER OF BIDDER CALCULATED LOW BIDR CALC BLANK NBR BIDDER NAME GROUP COMB GRP NBR GROUP TOTAL PRICE EXTENSIONS EXTENSIONS BID EXTENSION DIFF BIDS 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. NO ALT 375,819.21 * 375,819.22 375,819.22 * 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. NO ALT 385,468.78 385,468.78 385,468.78 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. NO ALT 433,501.88 433,801.88 433,501.88 300.00- 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. NO ALT 473,204.46 473,204.46 473,204.46 **** TOTAL GROUP NO ALT PAY ITEMS FOR THIS CONTRACT = 58 ---------------------- DETAIL CONTRACTOR BIDS ---------------------- ITEM NBR ITEM DESCRIPTION UNIT OF UNIT BIDDER CALCULATED BIDR CALC BIDR NBR BIDDER NAME QUANTITY MEASURE PRICE EXTENSION EXTENSION EXTENSION DIFF XX003424 CONN TO EXIST STRUCT 2.000 EACH 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 288.2400 576.48 576.48 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 347.9200 695.84 695.84 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 296.8900 593.78 593.78 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 424.0000 848.00 848.00 XX004039 STORM SEWER TAP 12 1.000 EACH 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 151.7100 151.71 151.71 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 361.1900 361.19 361.19 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 156.2600 156.26 156.26 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 318.0000 318.00 318.00 X3550200 BIT BC SUPER 5 38.000 SQ YD 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 49.0900 1,865.42 1,865.42 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 49.8400 1,893.92 1,893.92 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 43.1200 1,638.56 1,638.56 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 57.3500 2,179.30 2,179.30 20100110 TREE REMOV 6-15 102.000 UNIT 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 30.4300 3,103.86 3,103.86 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 28.8900 2,946.78 2,946.78 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 30.9000 3,151.80 3,151.80 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 18.1700 1,853.34 1,853.34 20100210 TREE REMOV OVER 15 76.000 UNIT 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 30.4300 2,312.68 2,312.68 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 34.6700 2,634.92 2,634.92 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 30.9000 2,348.40 2,348.40 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 18.1700 1,380.92 1,380.92 20200100 EARTH EXCAVATION 2,650.000 CU YD 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 7.2900 19,318.50 19,318.50 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 12.1800 32,277.00 32,277.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 14.0100 37,126.50 37,126.50 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 11.6600 30,899.00 30,899.00 20800250 TRENCH BACKFILL SPL 250.000 CU YD 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 32.7000 8,175.00 8,175.00 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 39.3200 9,830.00 9,830.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 33.6800 8,420.00 8,420.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 37.1000 9,275.00 9,275.00 21101615 TOPSOIL F & P 4 5,325.000 SQ YD 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 3.1200 16,614.00 16,614.00 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 1.9400 10,330.50 10,330.50 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 2.2700 12,087.75 12,087.75 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 2.7000 14,377.50 14,377.50 25000900 SEEDING CL 1 SPL .800 ACRE 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 2,276.8100 1,821.45 1,821.45 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 7,165.5800 5,732.46 5,732.46 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 2,060.0000 1,648.00 1,648.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 2,915.0000 2,332.00 2,332.00 28000250 TEMP EROS CONTR SEED 90.000 POUND 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 3.3700 303.30 303.30 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 2.3100 207.90 207.90 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 3.9100 351.90 351.90 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 2.1200 190.80 190.80 28000300 TEMP DITCH CHECKS 2.000 EACH 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 154.5100 309.02 309.02 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 159.1800 318.36 318.36 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 277.3900 554.78 554.78 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 103.8800 207.76 207.76 28000500 INLET & PIPE PROTECT 2.000 EACH 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 162.5200 325.04 325.04 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 130.2800 260.56 260.56 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 143.5500 287.10 287.10 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 106.0000 212.00 212.00 28000700 MULCH METHOD 1 .900 ACRE 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 1,366.0800 1,229.47 1,229.47 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 577.8700 520.08 520.08 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 1,236.0000 1,112.40 1,112.40 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 942.3400 848.11 848.11 30200650 PROCESS MOD SOIL 12 4,300.000 SQ YD 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 2.8500 12,255.00 12,255.00 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 2.8900 12,427.00 12,427.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 5.0400 21,672.00 21,672.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 2.6500 11,395.00 11,395.00 30201500 LIME 86.000 TON 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 64.8900 5,580.54 5,580.54 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 65.8800 5,665.68 5,665.68 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 58.7100 5,049.06 5,049.06 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 60.4200 5,196.12 5,196.12 35100500 AGG BASE CSE A 6 134.000 SQ YD 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 5.4300 727.62 727.62 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 12.4300 1,665.62 1,665.62 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 18.8500 2,525.90 2,525.90 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 11.0100 1,475.34 1,475.34 40200500 AGG SURF CSE A 6 304.000 SQ YD 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 7.1100 2,161.44 2,161.44 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 12.3300 3,748.32 3,748.32 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 19.8400 6,031.36 6,031.36 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 11.0100 3,347.04 3,347.04 40800010 BIT MATLS PR CT 71.000 GALLON 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 7.2400 514.04 514.04 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 7.3500 521.85 521.85 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 6.3600 451.56 451.56 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 7.4200 526.82 526.82 40800040 INCIDENTAL BIT SURF 21.000 TON 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 148.3400 3,115.14 3,115.14 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 150.6000 3,162.60 3,162.60 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 130.3100 2,736.51 2,736.51 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 164.5700 3,455.97 3,455.97 42000300 PCC PVT 8 3,311.000 SQ YD 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 38.1300 126,248.43 126,248.43 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 46.9200 155,352.12 155,352.12 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 55.3000 183,098.30 183,098.30 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 39.4900 130,751.39 130,751.39 42001300 PROTECTIVE COAT 4,404.000 SQ YD 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 0.0100 44.04 44.04 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 0.1600 704.64 704.64 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 0.0100 44.04 44.04 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 0.0100 44.04 44.04 42300200 PCC DRIVEWAY PAVT 6 139.000 SQ YD 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 44.9400 6,246.66 6,246.66 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 52.8800 7,350.32 7,350.32 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 46.2900 6,434.31 6,434.31 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 42.9300 5,967.27 5,967.27 42300400 PCC DRIVEWAY PAVT 8 209.000 SQ YD 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 50.1700 10,485.53 10,485.53 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 57.4800 12,013.32 12,013.32 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 51.6800 10,801.12 10,801.12 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 43.9900 9,193.91 9,193.91 42400100 PC CONC SIDEWALK 4 6,970.000 SQ FT 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 3.6000 25,092.00 25,092.00 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 4.5000 31,365.00 31,365.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 3.7100 25,858.70 25,858.70 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 3.5500 24,743.50 24,743.50 42400300 PC CONC SIDEWALK 6 800.000 SQ FT 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 4.2400 3,392.00 3,392.00 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 8.1700 6,536.00 6,536.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 4.3700 3,496.00 3,496.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 4.0800 3,264.00 3,264.00 42400410 PC CONC SIDEWALK 8 470.000 SQ FT 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 4.9100 2,307.70 2,307.70 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 10.0000 4,700.00 4,700.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 5.0600 2,378.20 2,378.20 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 4.8800 2,293.60 2,293.60 42400800 DETECTABLE WARNINGS 60.000 SQ FT 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 31.4200 1,885.20 1,885.20 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 32.5700 1,954.20 1,954.20 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 32.3600 1,941.60 1,941.60 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 8.5500 513.00 513.00 44000100 PAVEMENT REM 495.000 SQ YD 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 7.1500 3,539.25 3,539.25 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 6.7300 3,331.35 3,331.35 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 9.5900 4,747.05 4,747.05 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 16.9500 8,390.25 8,390.25 44000200 DRIVE PAVEMENT REM 510.000 SQ YD 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 7.1500 3,646.50 3,646.50 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 7.0100 3,575.10 3,575.10 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 8.3600 4,263.60 4,263.60 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 16.2700 8,297.70 8,297.70 44000300 CURB REM 40.000 FOOT 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 5.3600 214.40 214.40 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 4.5200 180.80 180.80 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 6.0500 242.00 242.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 8.4800 339.20 339.20 44000500 COMB CURB GUTTER REM 492.000 FOOT 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 5.3600 2,637.12 2,637.12 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 3.5200 1,731.84 1,731.84 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 5.9100 2,907.72 2,907.72 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 9.5400 4,693.68 4,693.68 44000600 SIDEWALK REM 985.000 SQ FT 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 0.8700 856.95 856.95 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 0.7800 768.30 768.30 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 2.1100 2,078.35 2,078.35 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 1.5900 1,566.15 1,566.15 48100700 AGGREGATE SHLDS A 8 18.000 SQ YD 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 22.2700 400.86 400.86 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 19.2300 346.14 346.14 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 35.8200 644.76 644.76 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 14.3100 257.58 257.58 50105210 REM EXIST CULVERTS 89.000 FOOT 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 6.2900 559.81 559.81 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 7.7900 693.31 693.31 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 11.2400 1,000.36 1,000.36 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 5.3000 471.70 471.70 550A2320 SS RG CL A 1 12 180.000 FOOT 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 31.5500 5,679.00 5,679.00 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 37.7500 6,795.00 6,795.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 32.5000 5,850.00 5,850.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 23.3200 4,197.60 4,197.60 550A2520 SS RG CL A 2 12 296.000 FOOT 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 31.5500 9,338.80 9,338.80 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 37.7500 11,174.00 11,174.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 32.5000 9,620.00 9,620.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 23.3200 6,902.72 6,902.72 56100600 WATER MAIN 6 115.000 FOOT 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 27.6100 3,175.15 3,175.15 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 34.1100 3,922.65 3,922.65 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 28.4400 3,270.60 3,270.60 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 42.4000 4,876.00 4,876.00 56104900 WATER VALVES 6 2.000 EACH 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 759.3300 1,518.66 1,518.66 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 935.3000 1,870.60 1,870.60 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 782.1100 1,564.22 1,564.22 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 848.0000 1,696.00 1,696.00 56108800 TAP VALVE & SLEEVE 6 1.000 EACH 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 1,765.5300 1,765.53 1,765.53 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 2,086.7500 2,086.75 2,086.75 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 1,818.5000 1,818.50 1,818.50 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 1,696.0000 1,696.00 1,696.00 56400100 FIRE HYDNTS TO BE MVD 2.000 EACH 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 1,100.7900 2,201.58 2,201.58 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 617.9300 1,235.86 1,235.86 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 1,133.8100 2,267.62 2,267.62 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 1,484.0000 2,968.00 2,968.00 60218400 MAN TA 4 DIA T1F CL 5.000 EACH 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 1,449.8400 7,249.20 7,249.20 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 1,536.1100 7,680.55 7,680.55 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 1,493.3400 7,466.70 7,466.70 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 1,431.0000 7,155.00 7,155.00 60242500 INLETS SPL N1 3.000 EACH 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 851.2400 2,553.72 2,553.72 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 827.4100 2,482.23 2,482.23 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 876.7800 2,630.34 2,630.34 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 795.0000 2,385.00 2,385.00 60242600 INLETS SPL N2 9.000 EACH 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 851.2400 7,661.16 7,661.16 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 827.4000 7,746.60 7,446.60 300.00- 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 876.7800 7,891.02 7,891.02 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 826.8000 7,441.20 7,441.20 60255600 MAN ADJUST SPL 2.000 EACH 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 424.1400 848.28 848.28 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 525.0400 1,050.08 1,050.08 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 1,133.0000 2,266.00 2,266.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 318.0000 636.00 636.00 60266600 VALVE BOX ADJ 1.000 EACH 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 126.7500 126.75 126.75 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 148.1100 148.11 148.11 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 206.0000 206.00 206.00 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 159.0000 159.00 159.00 60266910 VALVE BOX REMOVED 2.000 EACH 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 142.7900 285.58 285.58 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 33.0400 66.08 66.08 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 147.0700 294.14 294.14 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 212.0000 424.00 424.00 60500060 REMOV INLETS 1.000 EACH 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 138.1400 138.14 138.14 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 114.3600 114.36 114.36 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 154.5000 154.50 154.50 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 318.0000 318.00 318.00 60603300 GUTTER OUTLET 1.000 EACH 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 373.9600 373.96 373.96 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 431.3900 431.39 431.39 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 385.1800 385.18 385.18 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 318.0000 318.00 318.00 60605000 COMB CC&G TB6.24 1,809.000 FOOT 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 21.6600 39,182.94 39,182.94 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 22.4100 40,539.69 40,539.69 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 22.3100 40,358.79 40,358.79 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 17.4900 31,639.41 31,639.41 60618400 CONC MED TC4 20.000 SQ FT 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 18.0200 360.40 360.40 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 11.1900 223.80 223.80 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 18.5600 371.20 371.20 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 26.5000 530.00 530.00 66300105 CALCIUM CHLORIDE APLD 3.000 TON 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 0.0100 0.03 0.03 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 400.0000 1,200.00 1,200.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 0.0100 0.03 0.03 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 53.0000 159.00 159.00 67000500 ENGR FIELD OFFICE B 1.000 CAL MO 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 1,450.0000 1,450.00 1,450.00 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 1,400.0000 1,400.00 1,400.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 2,732.9400 2,732.94 2,732.94 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 848.0000 848.00 848.00 67100100 MOBILIZATION 1.000 L SUM 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 23,000.0000 23,000.00 23,000.00 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 9,386.0200 9,386.02 9,386.02 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 17,815.7500 17,815.75 17,815.75 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 3,286.0000 3,286.00 3,286.00 70101700 TRAF CONT & PROT 1.000 L SUM 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 6,350.3400 6,350.34 6,350.34 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 4,186.6400 4,186.64 4,186.64 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 4,568.9900 4,568.99 4,568.99 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 3,180.0000 3,180.00 3,180.00 78005100 EPOXY PVT MK LTR-SYM 17.600 SQ FT 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 4.2700 75.15 75.15 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 4.3300 76.21 76.21 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 3.8600 67.94 67.94 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 3.9800 70.05 70.05 78005110 EPOXY PVT MK LINE 4 1,621.000 FOOT 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 1.1400 1,847.94 1,847.94 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 1.1600 1,880.36 1,880.36 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 1.0300 1,669.63 1,669.63 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 1.0600 1,718.26 1,718.26 78005140 EPOXY PVT MK LINE 8 147.000 FOOT 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 2.2800 335.16 335.16 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 2.3100 339.57 339.57 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 2.0600 302.82 302.82 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 2.1200 311.64 311.64 78005150 EPOXY PVT MK LINE 12 679.000 FOOT 0385 Beniach Construction Co., Inc. 2.8500 1,935.15 1,935.15 0880 Central Illinois Tile Co. 2.8900 1,962.31 1,962.31 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 2.5800 1,751.82 1,751.82 0335 Otto Baum Company, Inc. 2.6500 1,799.35 1,799.35