ILLINOIS DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION PAGE: 1 08/28/03 08:12:33 U N I T P R I C E T A B U L A T I O N O F B I D S LETTING DATE: 08/01/2003 LETTING TYPE: SCHEDULED CONTRACT NUMBER: 72629 LETTING ITEM NUMBER: 102 RESPONSIBLE DISTRICT: 06 BIDS LOCKED: Y SECTION: E MADIGAN ST PK INTERNAL ROADS COUNTY: LOGAN ESTIMATE: -------------------------- SUMMARY OF CONTRACTOR BIDS -------------------------- "AS READ" SUMMATION SUMMATION OF NBR BIDR CONTR COMB ITEM CONTR BIDDER OF BIDDER CALCULATED LOW BIDR CALC BLANK NBR BIDDER NAME GROUP COMB GRP NBR GROUP TOTAL PRICE EXTENSIONS EXTENSIONS BID EXTENSION DIFF BIDS 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. NO ALT 1,150,344.08 1,150,344.08 1,150,344.08 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. NO ALT 1,120,390.53 * 1,120,390.54 1,120,390.54 * 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. NO ALT 1,148,213.22 1,148,213.22 1,148,213.22 **** TOTAL GROUP NO ALT PAY ITEMS FOR THIS CONTRACT = 66 ---------------------- DETAIL CONTRACTOR BIDS ---------------------- ITEM NBR ITEM DESCRIPTION UNIT OF UNIT BIDDER CALCULATED BIDR CALC BIDR NBR BIDDER NAME QUANTITY MEASURE PRICE EXTENSION EXTENSION EXTENSION DIFF A2003816 T-FRAXINUS PENN 2 10.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 299.2500 2,992.50 2,992.50 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 178.5000 1,785.00 1,785.00 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 290.7000 2,907.00 2,907.00 A2006416 T-QUERCUS ALBA 2 20.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 315.0000 6,300.00 6,300.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 194.2500 3,885.00 3,885.00 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 306.0000 6,120.00 6,120.00 A2006516 T-QUERCUS BICOL 2 10.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 341.2500 3,412.50 3,412.50 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 189.0000 1,890.00 1,890.00 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 331.5000 3,315.00 3,315.00 A2006712 T-QUERCUS MACR 1-1/2 20.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 262.5000 5,250.00 5,250.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 157.5000 3,150.00 3,150.00 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 255.0000 5,100.00 5,100.00 A2007114 T-QUERCUS RUBRA 1-3/4 20.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 288.7500 5,775.00 5,775.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 173.2500 3,465.00 3,465.00 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 280.5000 5,610.00 5,610.00 B2001168 T-CERCIS CAN CL 7' 20.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 215.2500 4,305.00 4,305.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 126.0000 2,520.00 2,520.00 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 209.1000 4,182.00 4,182.00 XX001472 WOOD BOLLARD 133.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 46.5100 6,185.83 6,185.83 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 106.9300 14,221.69 14,221.69 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 45.2000 6,011.60 6,011.60 XX003565 SEEDING SPEC COMPLETE 1.000 ACRE 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 735.0000 735.00 735.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 1,575.0000 1,575.00 1,575.00 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 714.0000 714.00 714.00 XZ127900 RETAINING WALL REMOV 110.000 FOOT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 25.7800 2,835.80 2,835.80 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 14.4600 1,590.60 1,590.60 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 22.9800 2,527.80 2,527.80 X0300266 WOODEN FENCE REMOV 300.000 FOOT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 1.0500 315.00 315.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 5.3000 1,590.00 1,590.00 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 2.0400 612.00 612.00 X0321083 PLASTIC CAR BUMPER 252.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 66.0000 16,632.00 16,632.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 63.3800 15,971.76 15,971.76 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 35.4100 8,923.32 8,923.32 X0323405 METAL SECURITY GATE 4.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 1,890.0000 7,560.00 7,560.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 3,507.4000 14,029.60 14,029.60 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 2,004.3000 8,017.20 8,017.20 X0324056 REM EX WOOD BOLLARD 40.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 10.5000 420.00 420.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 39.7800 1,591.20 1,591.20 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 10.2000 408.00 408.00 X0324057 WOODEN FENCE RELOCAT 240.000 FOOT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 4.2000 1,008.00 1,008.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 14.0100 3,362.40 3,362.40 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 6.1200 1,468.80 1,468.80 X3550010 BIT BC SUPER 4,264.000 TON 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 49.4000 210,641.60 210,641.60 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 44.7200 190,686.08 190,686.08 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 47.5700 202,838.48 202,838.48 X4066414 BC SC SUPER "C" N50 4,702.000 TON 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 53.5400 251,745.08 251,745.08 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 49.8900 234,582.78 234,582.78 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 49.5500 232,984.10 232,984.10 X4066765 LEV BIND MM SUPER N50 2,351.000 TON 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 60.1300 141,365.63 141,365.63 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 51.7500 121,664.25 121,664.25 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 60.7800 142,893.78 142,893.78 20100110 TREE REMOV 6-15 44.000 UNIT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 34.6500 1,524.60 1,524.60 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 57.7500 2,541.00 2,541.00 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 56.1000 2,468.40 2,468.40 20100210 TREE REMOV OVER 15 24.000 UNIT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 37.5900 902.16 902.16 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 57.7500 1,386.00 1,386.00 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 56.1000 1,346.40 1,346.40 20200100 EARTH EXCAVATION 2,009.000 CU YD 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 15.4500 31,039.05 31,039.05 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 34.6500 69,611.85 69,611.85 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 34.4100 69,129.69 69,129.69 20200500 EARTH EXC WID 527.000 CU YD 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 24.5800 12,953.66 12,953.66 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 22.1700 11,683.59 11,683.59 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 20.5600 10,835.12 10,835.12 25000100 SEEDING CL 1 3.000 ACRE 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 735.0000 2,205.00 2,205.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 1,102.5000 3,307.50 3,307.50 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 714.0000 2,142.00 2,142.00 25000400 NITROGEN FERT NUTR 540.000 POUND 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 0.9000 486.00 486.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 0.6300 340.20 340.20 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 0.8700 469.80 469.80 25000500 PHOSPHORUS FERT NUTR 540.000 POUND 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 0.9000 486.00 486.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 0.6300 340.20 340.20 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 0.8700 469.80 469.80 25000600 POTASSIUM FERT NUTR 540.000 POUND 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 0.9000 486.00 486.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 0.6300 340.20 340.20 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 0.8700 469.80 469.80 25001800 SEEDING CL 4 MOD 1.000 ACRE 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 3,097.5000 3,097.50 3,097.50 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 3,675.0000 3,675.00 3,675.00 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 3,009.0000 3,009.00 3,009.00 25001820 SEEDING CL 5 MOD 1.000 ACRE 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 4,200.0000 4,200.00 4,200.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 3,675.0000 3,675.00 3,675.00 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 4,080.0000 4,080.00 4,080.00 25100115 MULCH METHOD 2 6.000 ACRE 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 1,260.0000 7,560.00 7,560.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 945.0000 5,670.00 5,670.00 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 1,224.0000 7,344.00 7,344.00 28000300 TEMP DITCH CHECKS 22.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 246.7500 5,428.50 5,428.50 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 297.8700 6,553.14 6,553.14 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 84.2400 1,853.28 1,853.28 28000400 PERIMETER EROS BAR 13,191.000 FOOT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 4.1000 54,083.10 54,083.10 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 3.0000 39,573.00 39,573.00 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 2.2300 29,415.93 29,415.93 28000500 INLET & PIPE PROTECT 7.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 147.0000 1,029.00 1,029.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 122.6300 858.41 858.41 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 84.2400 589.68 589.68 28100725 STONE DUMP RIP CL B3 23.000 SQ YD 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 35.7000 821.10 821.10 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 64.0700 1,473.61 1,473.61 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 67.6500 1,555.95 1,555.95 28200100 FILTER FAB FOR RIPRAP 23.000 SQ YD 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 4.2000 96.60 96.60 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 6.4100 147.43 147.43 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 22.0800 507.84 507.84 31101200 SUB GRAN MAT B 4 132.000 SQ YD 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 10.4300 1,376.76 1,376.76 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 69.1400 9,126.48 9,126.48 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 17.5400 2,315.28 2,315.28 35100100 AGG BASE CSE A 3,004.000 TON 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 19.0500 57,226.20 57,226.20 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 21.8000 65,487.20 65,487.20 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 26.0900 78,374.36 78,374.36 35102400 AGG BASE CSE B 12 1,591.000 SQ YD 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 14.9800 23,833.18 23,833.18 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 12.9800 20,651.18 20,651.18 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 13.9800 22,242.18 22,242.18 35600300 BIT CONC BC WID 8 2,370.000 SQ YD 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 29.3100 69,464.70 69,464.70 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 22.2800 52,803.60 52,803.60 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 26.0500 61,738.50 61,738.50 40200300 AGG SURF CSE A 4 238.000 SQ YD 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 6.9900 1,663.62 1,663.62 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 10.8200 2,575.16 2,575.16 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 7.3000 1,737.40 1,737.40 40300400 BIT MATLS C&S CT 12.000 TON 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 338.9900 4,067.88 4,067.88 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 367.5000 4,410.00 4,410.00 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 470.3800 5,644.56 5,644.56 40300500 COVER COAT AGG 86.000 TON 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 46.0400 3,959.44 3,959.44 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 78.7500 6,772.50 6,772.50 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 44.1200 3,794.32 3,794.32 40300600 SEAL COAT AGG 43.000 TON 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 46.0400 1,979.72 1,979.72 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 78.7500 3,386.25 3,386.25 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 44.1200 1,897.16 1,897.16 40600200 BIT MATLS PR CT 106.000 TON 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 221.5200 23,481.12 23,481.12 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 0.0100 1.06 1.06 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 461.2500 48,892.50 48,892.50 40600300 AGG PR CT 211.000 TON 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 0.0100 2.11 2.11 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 0.0100 2.11 2.11 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 14.9500 3,154.45 3,154.45 40600980 BIT SURF REM BUTT JT 36.000 SQ YD 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 17.5000 630.00 630.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 24.6500 887.40 887.40 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 45.9600 1,654.56 1,654.56 40600990 TEMPORARY RAMP 36.000 SQ YD 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 17.5000 630.00 630.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 8.3000 298.80 298.80 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 6.8900 248.04 248.04 42400100 PC CONC SIDEWALK 4 700.000 SQ FT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 5.6700 3,969.00 3,969.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 4.2500 2,975.00 2,975.00 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 8.1700 5,719.00 5,719.00 44000600 SIDEWALK REM 375.000 SQ FT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 2.1000 787.50 787.50 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 2.2600 847.50 847.50 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 2.1100 791.25 791.25 44004400 PAVT REMOVAL SPL 5,549.000 SQ YD 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 4.3700 24,249.13 24,249.13 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 7.2300 40,119.27 40,119.27 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 6.4200 35,624.58 35,624.58 48101200 AGGREGATE SHLDS B 1,693.000 TON 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 25.0500 42,409.65 42,409.65 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 17.9400 30,372.42 30,372.42 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 20.0100 33,876.93 33,876.93 50105220 PIPE CULVERT REMOV 395.300 FOOT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 12.0800 4,775.22 4,775.22 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 11.6400 4,601.29 4,601.29 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 15.4800 6,119.24 6,119.24 54200637 P CUL 1 CS/A CP 12 165.400 FOOT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 46.8100 7,742.37 7,742.37 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 27.4900 4,546.85 4,546.85 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 30.2400 5,001.70 5,001.70 54200640 P CUL 1 CS/A CP 15 88.200 FOOT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 48.3500 4,264.47 4,264.47 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 27.1700 2,396.39 2,396.39 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 31.8700 2,810.93 2,810.93 54200649 P CUL 1 CS/A CP 24 74.500 FOOT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 68.2900 5,087.61 5,087.61 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 38.3800 2,859.31 2,859.31 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 40.4100 3,010.55 3,010.55 54200655 P CUL 1 CS/A CP 30 67.200 FOOT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 106.5100 7,157.47 7,157.47 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 48.0300 3,227.62 3,227.62 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 46.7500 3,141.60 3,141.60 54215547 MET END SEC 12 10.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 163.5500 1,635.50 1,635.50 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 226.1200 2,261.20 2,261.20 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 122.9500 1,229.50 1,229.50 54215550 MET END SEC 15 6.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 170.9800 1,025.88 1,025.88 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 232.8100 1,396.86 1,396.86 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 129.9100 779.46 779.46 54215559 MET END SEC 24 4.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 247.8000 991.20 991.20 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 268.4700 1,073.88 1,073.88 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 195.3400 781.36 781.36 54215565 MET END SEC 30 4.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 334.5300 1,338.12 1,338.12 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 351.6100 1,406.44 1,406.44 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 282.5300 1,130.12 1,130.12 61100605 MISC CONCRETE 20.500 CU YD 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 666.7500 13,668.38 13,668.38 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 1,231.4500 25,244.73 25,244.73 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 612.6900 12,560.15 12,560.15 67000400 ENGR FIELD OFFICE A 6.000 CAL MO 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 1,600.0000 9,600.00 9,600.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 557.1600 3,342.96 3,342.96 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 1,409.1500 8,454.90 8,454.90 67100100 MOBILIZATION 1.000 L SUM 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 16,388.0000 16,388.00 16,388.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 46,097.0100 46,097.01 46,097.01 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 3,870.8800 3,870.88 3,870.88 70101830 TRAF CONT-PROT BLR 21 1.000 L SUM 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 4,550.0000 4,550.00 4,550.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 2,732.8100 2,732.81 2,732.81 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 5,023.6400 5,023.64 5,023.64 70102620 TR CONT & PROT 701501 1.000 L SUM 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 14,100.0000 14,100.00 14,100.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 5,339.7000 5,339.70 5,339.70 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 10,974.5400 10,974.54 10,974.54 72000100 SIGN PANEL T1 15.750 SQ FT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 23.7600 374.22 374.22 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 23.6600 372.65 372.65 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 87.0500 1,371.04 1,371.04 78001100 PT PVT MK LTRS & SYMB 69.000 SQ FT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 1.5800 109.02 109.02 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 1.5800 109.02 109.02 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 1.5300 105.57 105.57 78001120 PAINT PVT MK LINE 5 10,620.000 FOOT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 0.3700 3,929.40 3,929.40 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 0.3700 3,929.40 3,929.40 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 0.3600 3,823.20 3,823.20