ILLINOIS DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION PAGE: 1 12/19/03 09:52:30 U N I T P R I C E T A B U L A T I O N O F B I D S LETTING DATE: 11/07/2003 LETTING TYPE: SCHEDULED CONTRACT NUMBER: 72787 LETTING ITEM NUMBER: 009 RESPONSIBLE DISTRICT: 06 BIDS LOCKED: Y SECTION: 2RS-2;10RS-1 COUNTY: LOGAN ESTIMATE: -------------------------- SUMMARY OF CONTRACTOR BIDS -------------------------- "AS READ" SUMMATION SUMMATION OF NBR BIDR CONTR COMB ITEM CONTR BIDDER OF BIDDER CALCULATED LOW BIDR CALC BLANK NBR BIDDER NAME GROUP COMB GRP NBR GROUP TOTAL PRICE EXTENSIONS EXTENSIONS BID EXTENSION DIFF BIDS 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. NO ALT 1,117,418.26 1,117,418.26 1,117,418.26 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company NO ALT 1,095,094.86 1,095,094.86 1,095,094.86 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. NO ALT 1,120,117.03 1,120,117.03 1,120,117.03 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. NO ALT 1,074,025.86 1,074,025.86 1,074,025.86 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. NO ALT 998,710.67 * 998,710.67 998,710.67 * **** TOTAL GROUP NO ALT PAY ITEMS FOR THIS CONTRACT = 33 ---------------------- DETAIL CONTRACTOR BIDS ---------------------- ITEM NBR ITEM DESCRIPTION UNIT OF UNIT BIDDER CALCULATED BIDR CALC BIDR NBR BIDDER NAME QUANTITY MEASURE PRICE EXTENSION EXTENSION EXTENSION DIFF XX004949 INCID BIT SUR SUPER 288.000 TON 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 114.9500 33,105.60 33,105.60 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 75.0000 21,600.00 21,600.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 101.0000 29,088.00 29,088.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 113.4800 32,682.24 32,682.24 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 81.9800 23,610.24 23,610.24 X4066414 BC SC SUPER "C" N50 13,274.000 TON 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 45.4500 603,303.30 603,303.30 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 39.6000 525,650.40 525,650.40 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 42.0000 557,508.00 557,508.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 41.6800 553,260.32 553,260.32 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 42.1900 560,030.06 560,030.06 35800100 PREPARATION OF BASE 230.000 SQ YD 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 8.4900 1,952.70 1,952.70 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 8.0000 1,840.00 1,840.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 15.0000 3,450.00 3,450.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 6.7100 1,543.30 1,543.30 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 15.1000 3,473.00 3,473.00 35800200 AGG BASE REPAIR 9.000 TON 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 50.0000 450.00 450.00 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 20.0000 180.00 180.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 25.0000 225.00 225.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 35.6000 320.40 320.40 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 40.5300 364.77 364.77 40200800 AGG SURF CSE B 23.000 TON 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 50.0000 1,150.00 1,150.00 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 20.0000 460.00 460.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 52.0100 1,196.23 1,196.23 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 69.3000 1,593.90 1,593.90 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 34.9200 803.16 803.16 40600200 BIT MATLS PR CT 67.000 TON 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 324.5000 21,741.50 21,741.50 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 235.0000 15,745.00 15,745.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 317.9100 21,299.97 21,299.97 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 406.4600 27,232.82 27,232.82 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 247.6100 16,589.87 16,589.87 40600300 AGG PR CT 1,672.000 TON 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 0.0100 16.72 16.72 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 0.0100 16.72 16.72 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 0.0100 16.72 16.72 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 0.0100 16.72 16.72 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 0.0100 16.72 16.72 40600895 CONSTRUC TEST STRIP 1.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 2,250.0000 2,250.00 2,250.00 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 3,000.0000 3,000.00 3,000.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 3,551.0000 3,551.00 3,551.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 2,290.9000 2,290.90 2,290.90 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 1,857.0700 1,857.07 1,857.07 40600980 BIT SURF REM BUTT JT 3,601.000 SQ YD 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 4.9500 17,824.95 17,824.95 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 3.0000 10,803.00 10,803.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 7.8100 28,123.81 28,123.81 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 6.3400 22,830.34 22,830.34 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 4.5200 16,276.52 16,276.52 40600985 PCC SURF REM BUTT JT 96.000 SQ YD 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 4.9500 475.20 475.20 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 10.0000 960.00 960.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 12.6500 1,214.40 1,214.40 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 11.1100 1,066.56 1,066.56 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 4.5200 433.92 433.92 40600990 TEMPORARY RAMP 87.000 SQ YD 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 10.3000 896.10 896.10 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 6.0000 522.00 522.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 12.5600 1,092.72 1,092.72 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 7.9400 690.78 690.78 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 6.5500 569.85 569.85 44000030 BIT SURF REM VAR DP 163,098.000 SQ YD 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 0.4200 68,501.16 68,501.16 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 0.7700 125,585.46 125,585.46 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 0.8500 138,633.30 138,633.30 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 0.7100 115,799.58 115,799.58 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 0.3700 60,346.26 60,346.26 44200144 PAVT PATCH T2 12 1,500.000 SQ YD 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 74.1800 111,270.00 111,270.00 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 86.0000 129,000.00 129,000.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 70.0000 105,000.00 105,000.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 78.9000 118,350.00 118,350.00 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 76.4300 114,645.00 114,645.00 44200148 PAVT PATCH T3 12 200.000 SQ YD 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 74.5400 14,908.00 14,908.00 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 83.0000 16,600.00 16,600.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 70.0000 14,000.00 14,000.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 78.9000 15,780.00 15,780.00 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 76.4300 15,286.00 15,286.00 44200150 PAVT PATCH T4 12 100.000 SQ YD 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 74.5400 7,454.00 7,454.00 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 82.0000 8,200.00 8,200.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 70.0000 7,000.00 7,000.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 78.9000 7,890.00 7,890.00 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 76.4300 7,643.00 7,643.00 48101200 AGGREGATE SHLDS B 3,887.000 TON 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 19.2400 74,785.88 74,785.88 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 14.0000 54,418.00 54,418.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 17.0000 66,079.00 66,079.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 11.4200 44,389.54 44,389.54 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 9.5600 37,159.72 37,159.72 48202000 BIT SHOULDERS SUPER 869.000 TON 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 43.1500 37,497.35 37,497.35 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 40.0000 34,760.00 34,760.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 41.4200 35,993.98 35,993.98 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 44.1200 38,340.28 38,340.28 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 38.9100 33,812.79 33,812.79 63100085 TRAF BAR TERM T6 4.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 1,733.1000 6,932.40 6,932.40 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 1,520.0000 6,080.00 6,080.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 1,635.0000 6,540.00 6,540.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 1,693.3800 6,773.52 6,773.52 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 1,716.7500 6,867.00 6,867.00 63100167 TR BAR TRM T1 SPL TAN 4.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 2,003.4000 8,013.60 8,013.60 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 1,920.0000 7,680.00 7,680.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 2,577.4900 10,309.96 10,309.96 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 1,772.4200 7,089.68 7,089.68 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 1,984.5000 7,938.00 7,938.00 63200310 GUARDRAIL REMOV 332.000 FOOT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 5.7300 1,902.36 1,902.36 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 6.1500 2,041.80 2,041.80 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 5.4000 1,792.80 1,792.80 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 5.4300 1,802.76 1,802.76 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 5.6700 1,882.44 1,882.44 63301210 REM RE-E SPBGR TY A 188.000 FOOT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 13.6200 2,560.56 2,560.56 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 13.0000 2,444.00 2,444.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 12.8500 2,415.80 2,415.80 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 16.4400 3,090.72 3,090.72 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 13.4900 2,536.12 2,536.12 67000400 ENGR FIELD OFFICE A 4.000 CAL MO 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 1,200.0000 4,800.00 4,800.00 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 2,000.0000 8,000.00 8,000.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 1,176.6700 4,706.68 4,706.68 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 1,024.6900 4,098.76 4,098.76 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 1,134.4700 4,537.88 4,537.88 67100100 MOBILIZATION 1.000 L SUM 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 16,000.0000 16,000.00 16,000.00 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 65,000.0000 65,000.00 65,000.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 5,002.4700 5,002.47 5,002.47 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 7,497.6500 7,497.65 7,497.65 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 5,131.1800 5,131.18 5,131.18 70100450 TRAF CONT-PROT 701201 1.000 L SUM 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 12,400.0000 12,400.00 12,400.00 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 6,000.0000 6,000.00 6,000.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 12,861.0300 12,861.03 12,861.03 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 8,100.0000 8,100.00 8,100.00 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 7,875.0000 7,875.00 7,875.00 70100460 TRAF CONT-PROT 701306 1.000 L SUM 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 24,496.3900 24,496.39 24,496.39 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 5,000.0000 5,000.00 5,000.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 12,375.2500 12,375.25 12,375.25 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 7,422.3100 7,422.31 7,422.31 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 26,739.2700 26,739.27 26,739.27 70300100 SHORT-TERM PAVT MKING 4,965.000 FOOT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 0.5000 2,482.50 2,482.50 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 0.5000 2,482.50 2,482.50 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 0.6500 3,227.25 3,227.25 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 0.7800 3,872.70 3,872.70 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 0.3800 1,886.70 1,886.70 70300230 TEMP PVT MK LINE 5 134,034.000 FOOT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 0.0100 1,340.34 1,340.34 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 0.0100 1,340.34 1,340.34 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 0.0100 1,340.34 1,340.34 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 0.0100 1,340.34 1,340.34 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 0.0100 1,340.34 1,340.34 70301000 WORK ZONE PAVT MK REM 1,655.000 SQ FT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 1.2900 2,134.95 2,134.95 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 1.0000 1,655.00 1,655.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 5.0000 8,275.00 8,275.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 1.1000 1,820.50 1,820.50 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 0.8900 1,472.95 1,472.95 78001120 PAINT PVT MK LINE 5 134,034.000 FOOT 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 0.1000 13,403.40 13,403.40 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 0.1100 14,743.74 14,743.74 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 0.1100 14,743.74 14,743.74 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 0.0900 12,063.06 12,063.06 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 0.1100 14,743.74 14,743.74 78100100 RAISED REFL PAVT MKR 937.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 21.2000 19,864.40 19,864.40 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 19.5000 18,271.50 18,271.50 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 15.8400 14,842.08 14,842.08 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 16.3200 15,291.84 15,291.84 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 19.4300 18,205.91 18,205.91 78200410 GUARDRAIL MKR TYPE A 16.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 8.4800 135.68 135.68 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 10.6500 170.40 170.40 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 8.0000 128.00 128.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 7.1800 114.88 114.88 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 8.4000 134.40 134.40 78201000 TERMINAL MARKER - DA 4.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 31.8000 127.20 127.20 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 40.0000 160.00 160.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 30.0000 120.00 120.00 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 17.0700 68.28 68.28 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 31.5000 126.00 126.00 78300200 RAISED REF PVT MK REM 937.000 EACH 0635 P. H. Broughton & Sons, Inc. 3.4600 3,242.02 3,242.02 0640 Chester Bross Construction Company 5.0000 4,685.00 4,685.00 1810 Truman L. Flatt & Sons Co., Inc. 8.5000 7,964.50 7,964.50 2807 Illinois Valley Paving Co. 10.1400 9,501.18 9,501.18 3990 Merrill's Contractors, Inc. 4.6700 4,375.79 4,375.79